We started our 2025 Alabama BBQ tour with Sally's Smokin' Butt BBQ located in DeKalb County (Ft. Payne). This area is home to the founding members of the group Alabama.
The restaurant is directly on U.S. Highway 11. Seeing this sight was nice as I always look for a stack of hickory wood at a BBQ joint. The aroma of smoking meat when you open the car door tells me we're on the right track.
We will put to the side our Kansas City BBQ Society training and not judge our offerings on the 2025 BBQ Tour as we would if we were judging competition level meat.
While we waited on our food to be delivered, I was amused to see The Andy Griffith Show on the television.
We'll start with Sweet Harold's lunch: He selected the combo plate and had a smoked chicken leg quarter and a rib. The combo plate came with his choice of two sides and garlic bread. He picked slaw and fries.
The rib had a mild smoke flavor and, yes, it did "fall off the bone." In competition judging, this would indicate a severely overcooked rib. But as we all know, this is the standard that nearly everyone references in describing a great rib.
The chicken leg quarter was beautifully cooked and was extremely tender. I believe SH wished he had paid the extra charge and had the half smoked chicken.
Now, my turn!
I almost always order the pulled pork at a BBQ restaurant. To me, that's a good baseline of the ability of the person in charge of smoking the meat. I decided on the baked beans and the fried sliced potatoes (which are an entirely different item than french fries which are also fried sliced potatoes, right?).
I almost always order the pulled pork at a BBQ restaurant. To me, that's a good baseline of the ability of the person in charge of smoking the meat. I decided on the baked beans and the fried sliced potatoes (which are an entirely different item than french fries which are also fried sliced potatoes, right?).
The pork wasn't technically the pulled version, but finely chopped. Again, the sauce was served on the side. We were both given two cups of sauce: one mild and one with a little more heat. I enjoyed the spicier one better.
The beans weren't what I would consider "baked beans." They didn't have the consistency or texture of a baked for a few hours baked beans. They were well seasoned.
The fried sliced potatoes are sliced thicker than house made potato chips, but thinner than potato wedges. I am a big fan of these yummy potatoes no matter what anyone chooses to call them.
Lastly, the garlic bread. A nice thick slice of the Texas Toast variety served warm. But here is where I had a slight moment of hesitation. It was seasoned with garlic, but not granulated garlic or garlic powder. There was a liberal dose of garlic salt. That wouldn't have been my choice to add garlic flavor to the bread and it may be great to some diners, but it was an overwhelming taste of salt for me.
Sweet tea (instead of my usual water or half/half tea) was amazing. Free refills and I enjoyed every sip!
We were offered a free sample of the banana pudding. When I tell you they saved the best for last, this pudding stole the show. No cool whip topping (YAY!!!) because to a true Southerner that's just wrong, but no meringue either. The pudding was definitely not from a can, but had that homemade flavor that is unmistakable. I could tell the pudding was fresh because the banana slices hadn't even thought about turning dark. Delicious.
The atmosphere was cozy and inviting. The dining room had a variety of locals. Service was prompt and helpful.
For me the stars of the meal included the smoked chicken, the fried sliced potatoes, and that banana pudding!